SIBGRAPI 2001 - Paper's Evaluation Form

--> Please return this form no later than June 15, 2001 <--
-->   to          sib2001@dca.fee.unicamp.br               <--

--- Part for committee use only     ------------------------
  Reviewer's Name:

  Highest degree:

  Affiliation:

  E-mail:

  Member of Program Committee who forwarded the paper:
  
Comments for the Program Committee (withheld from authors):





--- Part to be forwarded to authors ------------------------

Paper identification

  Number:

  Title: 

  Authors: 

Please use the following scales in your evaluations:

  1=very poor or strong reject     
  2=poor or reject
  3=marginal
  4=good or accept
  5=very good or strong accept

Briefly describe the paper and its contributions to the field.



Please rate the paper as to

  relevance to the Symposium's themes: 

  interest to the audience: 

  originality: 

  precision and thoroughness: 

  technical correctness: 

  clarity of exposition: 

  style, syntax, and spelling: 

Overall evaluation of the paper: 


Justification of the overall evaluation (4-7 lines):







Do the layout and typographical style of the paper follow the SIBGRAPI 2001
standard?
  [ ] Yes               [ ] No

Would this paper require much editorial rewriting?
  [ ] Yes               [ ] No

  
Do you recommend to select this paper for publishing in a journal: 
  [ ] Yes   [ ] Probably  [ ] Neutral  [ ] Doubtful   [ ] No

Which journal: [ ] Pattern Recognition Latters  [ ] Computers & Graphics

  
To assist the Program Committee in planing the technical program, please mark one
topic below to which this paper fits best
[ ] Animation and Simulation    [ ] Image Synthesis              [ ] Other
[ ] Computational Geometry      [ ] Image Compression              Please specify:
[ ] Computer Vision             [ ] Image Retrieval                
[ ] Geometric Modeling          [ ] Image Segmentation             ________________
[ ] Graphical Interface         [ ] Mathematical Morphology
[ ] Graphics Hardware           [ ] Pattern Recognition 
[ ] Graphical Data Structures   [ ] Visualization


How would you rate your competence in the paper's subject area:
   [ ] Low        [ ] Medium        [ ] High

   
Other comments to be forwarded to the authors: